Administrators and districts spend a lot of time on objectives, lesson plans and teaching strategies. All of that matters. None of it means anything if the teacher can’t get the room quiet enough to teach. I’m Spencer, the teacher behind World History Rawks, and this is how I handle middle school classroom management in my own 6th and 7th grade history classes, in a Q&A format.
Why does classroom management come first for you?
Spencer: I taught at a school one year where I was constantly interrupted. I couldn’t teach, and I eventually had a breakdown. That year taught me that the best lesson plan in the world doesn’t work if nobody can hear it. And that I didn’t deserve this battle everyday.
What’s your most important classroom rule?
Spencer: I have a simple rule: one person speaks at a time. Teacher or student, we give respect to whoever is speaking. Students hear it on the first day and I reinforce it whenver necessary.
How do you manage noise levels in a middle school classroom?
Spencer: I use four levels:
- Level 1: talking to a neighbor
- Level 2: answering a question
- Level 3: presenting to the class
- Level 4: too loud
Most of the day, the room should sit at a 1 or a 2. It should never feel uncomfortable. If a student asks to step outside because the room is too loud, the noise level has already gone too far.
There’s research behind keeping it down. In a 2019 study in the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 976 students ages 11 to 16 read texts and answered questions while recorded classroom noise played. At 70 decibels, every group answered fewer questions and got more of them wrong. At 64 decibels, the older students still did worse. For comparison, the U.S. classroom acoustics standard, ANSI/ASA S12.60, calls for no more than 35 decibels of background noise in an empty classroom. A busy room can easily climb past both numbers.
Sometimes classrooms should be loud … for a few moments. But it should not be the rule.
How do you start the first day of school?
Spencer: Before students ever walk in, I stand outside my classroom and tell them the most important thing to me is how we enter the room. “We enter quietly and get started silently.”
Then I tell them to walk in and line up along the back wall. I assign seats. Then we all go back outside and practice walking in again. After that, they start their bell ringer.
Once the bell ringer is done, I introduce myself and tell them the other thing that matters most to me: one person speaks at a time. Then we get started.
By the end of day one, every student knows two expectations that set up a successful class for the rest of the year.
What does the rest of the first week look like?
Spencer: Procedures before content. I use three lessons to teach them:
- Syllabus Scavenger Hunt: students hunt through the syllabus to find procedures and expectations, instead of sitting through a syllabus lecture.
- Classroom Expectations Matching Game: students sort safe vs. unsafe and appropriate vs. inappropriate behaviors. Students know right from wrong. This activity makes them take ownership right out of the gate.
- Classroom Management & Procedures: I chose one of these eight lessons with reading passages and behavior scenarios, so students think through each expectation instead of just hearing it. I take time to tell one of the craziest story of a student misbehaving and how I calmly handled it. I let students know, I do not argue. If a student can’t meet expectations, I will remove them from class.
Research backs this up. In a classic study by Emmer, Evertson and Anderson of how effective teachers start the year, the first weeks turned out to be crucial for classroom management in both elementary and secondary classrooms. That’s when the most effective teachers taught their expectations, procedures and routines.
How do you prepare students for activities like stations, simulations or tests?
Spencer: I tell students the behavior expectations for stations, simulations and tests before we do them, so they’re already conditioned for what to expect. They never walk into a new kind of activity guessing what’s allowed.
Simulations especially: they’re a privilege, not a free-for-all.
How does good curriculum help with classroom management?
Spencer: It follows a sequence: basics, then confidence, then creativity, then buy-in. Students learn the basics first. The basics give them confidence. Confidence gives them room to be creative with projects, posters and simulations. Variety and creativity gets their buy-in. And once students are bought in, classroom management gets a lot easier.
What should administrators do about classroom management?
Spencer: Admin need to set a campus-wide expectation for what classroom management looks like. Every teacher has their own style, but there should be things every class has in common. For instance, a class should never be so noisy that students ask to take a break outside.
That’s the teacher’s responsibility, but it’s also the administration’s. Teachers need to be supported when they remove students who keep contributing to the disruption.
Teachers have the right to teach. And students have the right to learn in a safe and calm environment.
What’s your advice for a teacher whose class is out of control right now?
Spencer: Make a list of what’s most important to you. If it’s noise level, entrance procedures and interruptions, write them down and decide ahead of time how you’ll respond to each one.
If you’re not ready, one of two things happens. You let it go until you overreact, or you won’t do anything at all.
Start the Year With Procedures
The three first-week lessons above, plus bell ringers, a pretest and more, are in my Back to School Bundle. You can see how I use each one in my back to school social studies activities post.
Try One Free First
Sign up and I’ll send you a no-prep activity for your first unit of the year.
